After a week of Vietnam remembrance stories from the corporate bootlicker media, culminating in today's marking of the 30th anniversary of the last American troops pulling out of Saigon, I found the stances of the two countries markedly different.
In Ho Chi Minh City, the natives bustle about on their mopeds, beeping in celebration. Here, we go through the usual honor-guard rituals of flag-folding and hand-holding.
This is not a small thing to me; a very dear uncle of mine did two tours in 'nam in the Marines, the second as a platoon leader. He went voluntarily -- unlike W., unlike Cheney, unlike Ted "I'm such a tough guy that I shit my pants and let it get caked in for ten days so the draft board would give me a psych deferment" Nugent -- because he had been told by his leaders that his country needed him.
He came back disillusioned and soaked in Agent Orange, doing drugs to kill the pain of having to do the things he did while he was there. He eventually died in 2001, right after his 52nd birthday, broke and burned-out, wasting away in a spare bedroom in his sister's single-wide while his transplanted liver went south on him, slowly, inexorably.
So I certainly feel for all those families profiled whose loved ones never came back, or who never even got any closure because they were MIA. It sucks. But it also sucks that the whole thing was preventable, that it never should have happened, that we visited unprecedented savagery on a nation that hadn't done shit to us, but refused to capitulate to us, no matter how dirty and scorched-earth we got on them.
What's amazing is how quickly the Vietnamese have forgiven us, and let it all go, and actually like us now. Think about it -- we carpet-bombed them for over a decade, killed enough of their civilian population to be counted in percentage points, and didn't even have the goddamn courtesy to be halfway gracious losers and throw them a freakin' bone -- and they let it all go, quite a while ago.
We still can't let it go; we still hang on to it furiously, tenaciously. We don't begrudge them, but losing sticks in our collective craw, so we can't admit it to ourselves. And it's a stain on our national soul, that dirty war, just as surely as slavery is, if not quite the same in degree. Reparation would have been a small chance to absolve some of that collective guilt, and we passed it up vaingloriously, because that's how we do things. As with slavery, that chance has long since passed, so we occasionally pick at the scab that has festered in its place for so long.
We had to work it out with a seemingly endless set of cathartic movies. It's a sad statement, a culture that can only assuage itself with Deerhunter and Platoon, rather than just looking itself in the eye and coming clean. Certainly it's not a unique phenomenon; Germany has its periodic spasms of post-Nazi nationalism, knowing better but needing to expunge its baser nationalist guilt somehow, someway. Still, sometimes you actually have to do things that demonstrate you're better than all the rest, rather than just repeating it like a mantra.
I respectfully suggest that if we want to do more with our commemorations of a dismal day which capped a nightmarish decade -- do something more than dick around with flag rituals and ogle cenotaphs -- we may pay a bit more attention to how we are collectively handling our current conflict, and the accountability of our leaders who may just be lying still, and always, while our brothers and sisters and uncles go hither and yon to chase shadows for a feckless little man and his pelf-grubbing henchmen.
And we may ponder for a second, in the service of our vaunted Judeo-Christian ethical code, which is centered really around but one golden rule -- do unto others as you would have others do unto you -- and wonder what exactly the Vietnamese might know that we don't. We lost three thousand people in a senseless morning of violence, and we've spent every minute since turning the world upside down in a reactive rage, and altered human history for all time. And we'll keep doing it for an undetermined amount of time, blood, and resources.
They lost three million people over the course of a brutal, unremitting invasion, after decades of colonialism -- and when it was all over, they picked themselves up, brushed themselves off, and went right back to what they had been doing. That was their only option, so they took it.
We have all options at our disposal and strangely, we jumped at the worst one, even though we had supposedly learned our lesson from before.
48 comments:
Hi I just wanted to send a quick note to let you know I really enjoyed
That is a good point. I found another bmw tuning site that goes into even more bmw tuningdetail.
Great blog you have. I have a site about mel bays complete bluegrass banjo method book. You can check it out at mel bays complete bluegrass banjo method book
Hello Heywood J. Im looking for sites with information about allen carpet cleaning and found your site. Even though Charlie Don't Grudge is different than what i was looking for I found it intresting i see why your blog got my attention when i was looking for allen carpet cleaning related blogs I am glad I stopped by even though its not a perfect match Great Post! I enjoyed it Great Read! I have a Carpet Cleaning Company with a pretty good website allen carpet cleaning it has some good information on on carpet stains and pet odor if you ever need some advice on those things.
Thanks again
Sterling Myers
I'm always looking for a place where I can learn more about forex, forex trading, forex trade and improve my online profit. I will be keeping an eye on your blog as I liked it a lot. Another site I found with forex trade resources is forex trade
I came across a 2005 ford focus that I think will interest you. Bookmark it and come back often. I know it has some great 2005 ford focusinfo.
Hello Heywood J. Im looking for sites with information about dallas carpet cleaning and found your site. Even though Charlie Don't Grudge is different than what i was looking for I found it intresting i see why your blog got my attention when i was looking for dallas carpet cleaning related blogs I am glad I stopped by even though its not a perfect match Great Post! I enjoyed it Great Read! I have a Carpet Cleaning Company with a pretty good website dallas carpet cleaning it has some good information on on carpet stains and pet odor if you ever need some advice on those things.
Thanks again
Sterling Myers
Hello Heywood J. Im looking for sites with information about carpet cleaning frisco and found your site. Even though Charlie Don't Grudge is different than what i was looking for I found it intresting i see why your blog got my attention when i was looking for carpet cleaning frisco related blogs I am glad I stopped by even though its not a perfect match Great Post! I enjoyed it Great Read! I have a Carpet Cleaning Company with a pretty good website carpet cleaning frisco it has some good information on on carpet stains and pet odor if you ever need some advice on those things.
Thanks again
Sterling Myers
Hello Heywood J. Im looking for sites with information about dallas carpet cleaning and found your site. Even though Charlie Don't Grudge is different than what i was looking for I found it intresting i see why your blog got my attention when i was looking for dallas carpet cleaning related blogs I am glad I stopped by even though its not a perfect match Great Post! I enjoyed it Great Read! I have a Carpet Cleaning Company with a pretty good website dallas carpet cleaning it has some good information on on carpet stains and pet odor if you ever need some advice on those things.
Thanks again
Sterling Myers
High Google and Yahoo link popularity can be yours,
I love your green bay packer official web site blog! Check out my green bay packer official web site forum for lots of great green bay packer official web site info.
Hello Heywood J. Im looking for sites with information about carpet cleaning dallas and found your site. Even though Charlie Don't Grudge is different than what i was looking for I found it intresting i see why your blog got my attention when i was looking for carpet cleaning dallas related blogs I am glad I stopped by even though its not a perfect match Great Post! I enjoyed it Great Read! I have a Carpet Cleaning Company with a pretty good website carpet cleaning dallas it has some good information on on carpet stains and pet odor if you ever need some advice on those things.
Thanks again
Sterling Myers
I just came across your blog about national bank of arizona and wanted to drop you a note telling you how impressed I was with the information you have posted here. I also have a web site about national bank of arizona so I know what I'm talking about when I say your site is top-notch! Keep up the great work, you are providing a great resource on the Internet here! If you get a chance, please stop by national bank of arizona
putting to waste some good money that could have been used in other areas of development for the business involved.
Learn how to quickly create an RSS feeds with our RSS feeder, for high link popularity and ultimately better search engine rankings.
Hello -> Heywood J. <- I just wanted to let you know that Charlie Don't Grudge was an interesting read and well presented. Just my two cents.
Regards,
Emotional and Mental Self Improvement
Hello -> Heywood J. <- I just wanted to let you know that Charlie Don't Grudge was an interesting read and well presented. Just my two cents.
Regards,
Self Improvement
Greatest Blog Post. Please visit this site on compare long distance phone plan
compare long distance phone plan
I discuss this topic daily myself. I also have a website that talks about online paid survey yahoo.com related things. Go check it out if you get a chance.
Hello Heywood J. Im looking for sites with information about carpet cleaning dallas and found your site. Even though Charlie Don't Grudge is different than what i was looking for I found it intresting i see why your blog got my attention when i was looking for carpet cleaning dallas related blogs I am glad I stopped by even though its not a perfect match Great Post! I enjoyed it Great Read! I have a Carpet Cleaning Company with a pretty good website carpet cleaning dallas it has some good information on on carpet stains and pet odor if you ever need some advice on those things.
Thanks again
Sterling Myers
Hello Heywood J. Im looking for sites with information about carpet cleaning allen and found your site. Even though Charlie Don't Grudge is different than what i was looking for I found it intresting i see why your blog got my attention when i was looking for carpet cleaning allen related blogs I am glad I stopped by even though its not a perfect match Great Post! I enjoyed it Great Read! I have a Carpet Cleaning Company with a pretty good website carpet cleaning allen it has some good information on on carpet stains and pet odor if you ever need some advice on those things.
Thanks again
Sterling Myers
Hello Heywood J., been looking for the latest info on california dui and found Charlie Don't Grudge. Though not exactly what I was searching for, it did get my attention. Interesting post, thanks for a great read.
Hi there Heywood J., I had been out looking for some new information on dui attorneys when I found your site and Charlie Don't Grudge. Though not just what I was searching for, it drew my attention. An interesting post and I thank you for it.
Hello Heywood J. Im looking for sites with information about carpet cleaning allen and found your site. Even though Charlie Don't Grudge is different than what i was looking for I found it intresting i see why your blog got my attention when i was looking for carpet cleaning allen related blogs I am glad I stopped by even though its not a perfect match Great Post! I enjoyed it Great Read! I have a Carpet Cleaning Company with a pretty good website carpet cleaning allen it has some good information on on carpet stains and pet odor if you ever need some advice on those things.
Thanks again
Sterling Myers
Hi there Heywood J., I had been out looking for some new information on expunge a dui when I found your site and Charlie Don't Grudge. Though not just what I was searching for, it drew my attention. An interesting post and I thank you for it.
Hi there Heywood J., I had been out looking for some new information on dui conviction when I found your site and Charlie Don't Grudge. Though not just what I was searching for, it drew my attention. An interesting post and I thank you for it.
Hello Heywood J. Im looking for sites with information about carpet cleaning plano and found your site. Even though Charlie Don't Grudge is different than what i was looking for I found it intresting i see why your blog got my attention when i was looking for carpet cleaning plano related blogs I am glad I stopped by even though its not a perfect match Great Post! I enjoyed it Great Read! I have a Carpet Cleaning Company with a pretty good website carpet cleaning plano it has some good information on on carpet stains and pet odor if you ever need some advice on those things.
Thanks again
Sterling Myers
Hello Heywood J. Im looking for sites with information about carpet cleaning frisco and found your site. Even though Charlie Don't Grudge is different than what i was looking for I found it intresting i see why your blog got my attention when i was looking for carpet cleaning frisco related blogs I am glad I stopped by even though its not a perfect match Great Post! I enjoyed it Great Read! I have a Carpet Cleaning Company with a pretty good website carpet cleaning frisco it has some good information on on carpet stains and pet odor if you ever need some advice on those things.
Thanks again
Sterling Myers
Hello Heywood J. Im looking for sites with information about carpet cleaning frisco and found your site. Even though Charlie Don't Grudge is different than what i was looking for I found it intresting i see why your blog got my attention when i was looking for carpet cleaning frisco related blogs I am glad I stopped by even though its not a perfect match Great Post! I enjoyed it Great Read! I have a Carpet Cleaning Company with a pretty good website carpet cleaning frisco it has some good information on on carpet stains and pet odor if you ever need some advice on those things.
Thanks again
Sterling Myers
Hello Heywood J. Im looking for sites with information about allen carpet cleaning and found your site. Even though Charlie Don't Grudge is different than what i was looking for I found it intresting i see why your blog got my attention when i was looking for allen carpet cleaning related blogs I am glad I stopped by even though its not a perfect match Great Post! I enjoyed it Great Read! I have a Carpet Cleaning Company with a pretty good website allen carpet cleaning it has some good information on on carpet stains and pet odor if you ever need some advice on those things.
Thanks again
Sterling Myers
Hello Heywood J. Im looking for sites with information about carpet cleaning dallas and found your site. Even though Charlie Don't Grudge is different than what i was looking for I found it intresting i see why your blog got my attention when i was looking for carpet cleaning dallas related blogs I am glad I stopped by even though its not a perfect match Great Post! I enjoyed it Great Read! I have a Carpet Cleaning Company with a pretty good website carpet cleaning dallas it has some good information on on carpet stains and pet odor if you ever need some advice on those things.
Thanks again
Sterling Myers
Hi there Heywood J., I had been out looking for some new information on dwi when I found your site and Charlie Don't Grudge. Though not just what I was searching for, it drew my attention. An interesting post and I thank you for it.
Hi there Heywood J., I had been out looking for some new information on expunge a dui when I found your site and Charlie Don't Grudge. Though not just what I was searching for, it drew my attention. An interesting post and I thank you for it.
Hello Heywood J., been looking for the latest info on dui attorneys and found Charlie Don't Grudge. Though not exactly what I was searching for, it did get my attention. Interesting post, thanks for a great read.
Hi Heywood J., Out surfing for information on dui & happened upon your site. While Charlie Don't Grudge wasn't exactly spot on, it did strike a note with me. Thank you for the really good read.
Hello Heywood J., been looking for the latest info on dui attorneys and found Charlie Don't Grudge. Though not exactly what I was searching for, it did get my attention. Interesting post, thanks for a great read.
Hi Heywood J., Out surfing for information on dwi & happened upon your site. While Charlie Don't Grudge wasn't exactly spot on, it did strike a note with me. Thank you for the really good read.
Hi there. Nice blog. Interesting posts. Looking for updated information about day trading. Not quite what I had in mind, but very nice read none the less. I have a day tradingrelated site. Maybe visit if you have time Free-Cash-Site.com. Thanks.
Hi Heywood J.
I was look at some different blogs to get an idea of how they work because I'am new at using blogs. Im glad I stoped at ur site I found it intersting thanks for read
I have a carpet cleaning blog Charlie Don't Grudge at http://www.carpet-cleaning-dallas-allen-frisco-plano-texas.com
If you have any problem stains in Your carpet at home u can check out my carpet cleaning website for tips on carpet stain removal
At carpet cleaning plano site It pretty much covers carpet cleaning plano and related stuff.
Come and check it out if you get time :-)
Take Care And Thanks
Sterling Myers
Hi Heywood J.
I was look at some different blogs to get an idea of how they work because I'am new at using blogs. Im glad I stoped at ur site I found it intersting thanks for read
I have a carpet cleaning blog Charlie Don't Grudge at http://www.carpet-cleaning-dallas-allen-frisco-plano-texas.com
If you have any problem stains in Your carpet at home u can check out my carpet cleaning website for tips on carpet stain removal
At carpet cleaning allen site It pretty much covers carpet cleaning allen and related stuff.
Come and check it out if you get time :-)
Take Care And Thanks
Sterling Myers
Hi Heywood J.
I was look at some different blogs to get an idea of how they work because I'am new at using blogs. Im glad I stoped at ur site I found it intersting thanks for read
I have a carpet cleaning blog Charlie Don't Grudge at http://www.carpet-cleaning-dallas-allen-frisco-plano-texas.com
If you have any problem stains in Your carpet at home u can check out my carpet cleaning website for tips on carpet stain removal
At frisco carpet cleaning site It pretty much covers frisco carpet cleaning and related stuff.
Come and check it out if you get time :-)
Take Care And Thanks
Sterling Myers
Hi Heywood J.
I was look at some different blogs to get an idea of how they work because I'am new at using blogs. Im glad I stoped at ur site I found it intersting thanks for read
I have a carpet cleaning blog Charlie Don't Grudge at http://www.carpet-cleaning-dallas-allen-frisco-plano-texas.com
If you have any problem stains in Your carpet at home u can check out my carpet cleaning website for tips on carpet stain removal
At carpet cleaning dallas site It pretty much covers carpet cleaning dallas and related stuff.
Come and check it out if you get time :-)
Take Care And Thanks
Sterling Myers
Hi Heywood J.
I was look at some different blogs to get an idea of how they work because I'am new at using blogs. Im glad I stoped at ur site I found it intersting thanks for read
I have a carpet cleaning blog Charlie Don't Grudge at http://www.carpet-cleaning-dallas-allen-frisco-plano-texas.com
If you have any problem stains in Your carpet at home u can check out my carpet cleaning website for tips on carpet stain removal
At allen carpet cleaning site It pretty much covers allen carpet cleaning and related stuff.
Come and check it out if you get time :-)
Take Care And Thanks
Sterling Myers
Hi Heywood J.
I was look at some different blogs to get an idea of how they work because I'am new at using blogs. Im glad I stoped at ur site I found it intersting thanks for read
I have a carpet cleaning blog Charlie Don't Grudge at http://www.carpet-cleaning-dallas-allen-frisco-plano-texas.com
If you have any problem stains in Your carpet at home u can check out my carpet cleaning website for tips on carpet stain removal
At frisco carpet cleaning site It pretty much covers frisco carpet cleaning and related stuff.
Come and check it out if you get time :-)
Take Care And Thanks
Sterling Myers
Hi Heywood J.
I was look at some different blogs to get an idea of how they work because I'am new at using blogs. Im glad I stoped at ur site I found it intersting thanks for read
I have a carpet cleaning blog Charlie Don't Grudge at http://www.carpet-cleaning-dallas-allen-frisco-plano-texas.com
If you have any problem stains in Your carpet at home u can check out my carpet cleaning website for tips on carpet stain removal
At allen carpet cleaning site It pretty much covers allen carpet cleaning and related stuff.
Come and check it out if you get time :-)
Take Care And Thanks
Sterling Myers
Hi Heywood J.
I was look at some different blogs to get an idea of how they work because I'am new at using blogs. Im glad I stoped at ur site I found it intersting thanks for read
I have a carpet cleaning blog Charlie Don't Grudge at http://www.carpet-cleaning-dallas-allen-frisco-plano-texas.com
If you have any problem stains in Your carpet at home u can check out my carpet cleaning website for tips on carpet stain removal
At carpet cleaning frisco site It pretty much covers carpet cleaning frisco and related stuff.
Come and check it out if you get time :-)
Take Care And Thanks
Sterling Myers
Hi Heywood J.
I was look at some different blogs to get an idea of how they work because I'am new at using blogs. Im glad I stoped at ur site I found it intersting thanks for read
I have a carpet cleaning blog Charlie Don't Grudge at http://www.carpet-cleaning-dallas-allen-frisco-plano-texas.com
If you have any problem stains in Your carpet at home u can check out my carpet cleaning website for tips on carpet stain removal
At dallas carpet cleaning site It pretty much covers dallas carpet cleaning and related stuff.
Come and check it out if you get time :-)
Take Care And Thanks
Sterling Myers
Hi Heywood J.
I was look at some different blogs to get an idea of how they work because I'am new at using blogs. Im glad I stoped at ur site I found it intersting thanks for read
I have a carpet cleaning blog Charlie Don't Grudge at http://www.carpet-cleaning-dallas-allen-frisco-plano-texas.com
If you have any problem stains in Your carpet at home u can check out my carpet cleaning website for tips on carpet stain removal
At carpet cleaning dallas site It pretty much covers carpet cleaning dallas and related stuff.
Come and check it out if you get time :-)
Take Care And Thanks
Sterling Myers
Post a Comment